top of page

The Heart of the Matter, Part 1

Writer: thehealingriverllc
thehealingriverllc
Aug 1
10 min read

Tell a lie big enough an’ long enough, an’ people will believe it


Audio narration coming soon to YouTube


Adjacent to the City of Milton you’ll find the Village of Bagdad. This tiny dot on Florida’s map had been wrapped in briars, mosquitoes, thorns, an’ snakes for a million years. But before they measured off their boundaries to make a respectable showin’ as real communities, it was all called Hell-Town. Sometimes, Hard Scrabble. That’s always been my favorite. There’s somethin’ honest about it.


By the time my family moved in a lot had changed. But in ever’ way that really mattered, it was mostly still the same. Prosperity might be rollin’ in on freight trains for most people in 1958, but in this part of the world? It was all just a lot o’ Hard Scrabble.

Not that it started out that way.


Bagdad was founded in the early 1800s when Joseph Forsyth an’ his partners, Andrew an’ Ezekiel Simpson, decided this was a good place to make a fine livin’. When Mr. Forsyth arrived, longleaf pine forests stretched out in ever’ direction. Part of the Southern Yellow Pine family, they’s prob’ly here with the dinosaurs.


More’n 80 million acres grew from Virginia to Texas coverin’ the entire panhandle of Florida where I lived, an’ a good part of the rest of the state. When Mr. Forsyth an’ the Simpson brothers built their sawmill in Bagdad, they had what looked like an unendin’ supply.


These were virgin forests, trees never touched by human hands. Towerin’ well over a hundred feet tall, an’ hundreds of years old, these giants could achieve diameters of up to six feet or more. But the real treasure was hidden deep within that spectacular span, like a secret waitin’ to be uncovered.


Heartwood.


It takes up to 200 years for these trees to fill themselves up with a heart so dense an’ resin-rich, rot would never dare attack. Life moves at a slow pace in this part of the world. So, nobody minded.


When John Forsyth’s money an’ the Simpson brothers skill joined forces, old growth pine forests rich with heartwood were plentiful. Slave labor that built Mr. Forsyth’s mills helped Bagdad become the economic center of Florida’s panhandle. Known around the world as The Prince of Wood for its strength and durability, Southern yellow longleaf pine was at the heart of that growth.


Antebellum mansions built with yellow pine heartwood were financed through slave labor an’ maintained by the same. These magnificent structures boasted of gable roofs with Greek-style pillars an’ a central entryway leadin’ to a grand staircase.


They had wrap around balconies coverin’ porches where the lady of the house could sip a cool drink while her children played on a well-manicured lawn. The porte-cochere offered shade an’ shelter, allowin’ travelers to step from carriage to house without facin’ the scorchin’ sun or the wild pop-up rainstorms that come with it.


Corn bread an’ beans, turnip greens an’ sweet tea, followed by a large servin’ of blackberry cobbler graced ever’ table from antebellum mansion to the kitchen cottage that sat next to ‘em, an’ the slave shacks hidden out back. Bagdad was no exception to these traditions.


In 1860, just before the Civil War began, Santa Rosa County was the richest in the state. Milton an’ Bagdad’s old-growth pine forest heartwood were the reason why.


At the start of the war, lumber mills all along the Gulf Coast flourished, providin’ employment for most families. But when the Union Army took control of this waterway on a windy day in March 1862, the Confederacy burned ever’ mill to the ground, refusin’ to give any economic sustenance to their northern enemies.


Sparks from the massive fires along Blackwater River were picked up by the wind an’ carried into town. Destroyed nearly ever’thing. Some of the most beautiful homes in the village were among the casualties.


When the war ended a few years later, those mills, along with some grand homes, were rebuilt. Ezekiel Simpson was smart enough to stash money away in New York rather than invest in the Confederacy. That decision proved to be somethin’ akin to divine guidance.


By the turn of the 20th century, what is now a quiet southern village had once again become the largest producer of yellow pine lumber in the world. Ever’where they looked, lumber yard an’ sawmill owners saw cash growin’ right outta the ground. It was a time when money really did grow on trees. 


But the unsustainable clearin’ of millions of acres of yellow pines decimated the very resource that had created a thrivin’ economy. Early in 1929 an article in Milton’s Santa Rosa Press Gazette boldly declared, "There is at least 100 years of lumber left."  Ten years later, it was all gone.


During the 1930s depression, one by one, lumber yards shut down as families moved away. Old growth yellow pine forests an’ the heartwood they possessed were harvested almost to extinction. A few of these forests still exist but they are very hard to find. Mother Nature said enough is enough. She took her treasure into her heart, into the deep woods, where it could be held safe from man’s greed an’ destruction.


By the time World War II started, Bagdad had fallen into a deep slumber. Most businesses had either closed their doors or moved away along with the folks who patronized ‘em. Once the richest community in the county that lived off the fat of the land, Bagdad was now payin’ for their overindulgence.


The fat livin’ of the past had attacked the heart of a community. It put the whole place on life support. It made this tiny dot on the map a mere shadow of its former self.


Bagdad’s actions became a lesson in “you reap what you sow.” By the time we arrived in this part of the country, that reapin’ was in full swing. Bagdad stood as a testament to thousands of years of patience eaten up in a few short decades of greed.


The grandeur of a slave driven economy was shattered when the North won the Civil War. The land lay in ruins. Proud men who held Southern ideals close to their hearts were laid low as families lost ever’thing.


The rape of Virgin Forests that followed the loss of slave labor, exhausted the natural resource that might’ve fought the comin’ hardships. Poverty grew by leaps an’ bounds, gainin’ strength well beyond World War II. But Southern ideals, like state’s rights to defend the so-called Southern way of life, did not allow for an honest reckonin’ with their demise.


More’n anything else the South’s central belief was based on what Confederate Vice President Alexander H. Stephens called the great truth. He declared, “The negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery, subordination to the superior race, is his natural and normal condition." – March 21, 1861, Cornerstone Speech. This ideal was at the heart of ever’thing the South stood for. Before the war, an’ after.


Today, although not quite so magnificent as a plantation house, Bagdad homes carry an air about ‘em that whispers of life before The Civil War. A hundred years later, this model of southern livin’ had become my home. But the grandeur of its past had long faded into history. By the time we moved in, heartwood was gone, an’ Hard Scrabble was back.



When I’s a little girl, on any given Sunday, the sweet aroma of fried chicken an’ freshly baked biscuits wafted through the air from ever’ kitchen window in town. A lot had changed in a hundred years, but a lot had stayed the same.


Bagdad Elementary School was where my favorite teacher, Mrs. Allen, taught 1st grade. I loved the way the skin on her upper arms flapped back an’ forth when she wrote on the blackboard. I couldn’t wait for the day when my arms looked like hers. She was my hero an’ I loved her like she was my Mama.


In the backyard playground, Spanish moss draped across two-hundred-year-old Live Oak tree limbs the size of culvert pipes, swayin’ in the summer breeze like slow motion was the only speed allowed. The heat alone was enough to put life in low gear. Hot, sun-bathed pavement shimmered in waves risin’ up into an already meltin’ community.


As a young child, my home, like most others, had no air conditionin’. Sometimes it felt like I’s breathin’ under water. Humidity could rise on hot summer days to 100% without bringin’ a drop of rain to ease your misery. No wonder this community was named after the capital of Iraq. It was hot.


From mansion to slave shack, from Live Oak to Yellow Pine, from cornbread an’ cobbler to sweet iced tea, life here carried an invitation to slow down an’ catch your breath. Practicin’ patience wasn’t just a necessity; it was a fine-tuned skill. The heart of the culture I lived in was never in a rush, ‘specially when it came to change.



In 1996 I’s sittin’ at a popular Nashville restaurant with my sister Bonnie an’ her husband. We had just arrived. While lookin’ at the menu, Bonnie began to address those of us at the table, along with ever’body else in the room.


Her louder-n-life southern accent married Arkansas Ozark twang with a Deep South drawl. Add to that her unique high-pitch voice, an’ diphthongs never went on a ride like the one she’d give ‘em. Today was no different.


Bonnie had been sick for years. All her life, really. It’s no wonder the medicine that kept her alive, along with the disease that ravaged her body, had unintended consequences. Just about anything that came outta her mouth promised to be memorable, never predictable. I’s always prepared for the unknown.


“Wally Faye, did you know that slaves really had it good? Most plantation owners took care of their slaves like they’s family. Slaves were happy. The South losin’ The Civil War caused ‘em more problems than bein’ a slave did.”


I’s just about to take a drink of water when the cup paused an inch from my lips. I looked at her with my mouth hangin’ open, wonderin’ how a person could repeat the word slave with that much regularity in such a short span of time.


“Lyle an’ I went on a tour of Andrew Jackson’s home, The Hermitage. Gave me chills just bein’ there. Oh, an’ how he loved his wife, Rachel. They were devoted to each other. We met a group of people there while we’s on the tour. Spent most of the afternoon talkin’ to ‘em. They’s the ones who told me all about slavery an’ how good it was for the coloreds.”

Lookin’ around the room I counted at least four tables filled with my sister’s “coloreds.” One couple sat right next to us.


“Bonnie! That is crazy! Slavery was horrible,” I answered quietly.


“I know that’s what ever’body thinks. But it ain’t true.” She continued. “Andrew Jackson an’ his wife Rachel owned more’n 150 slaves. They’s good to ‘em. Nobody can tell me any different. It’s part of the history of The Hermitage. Aunt Hannah said her years spent in slavery there were the happiest of her life. It was no slavery to her. She kept workin’ there even after she was freed.”


“But, Bonnie,” I whispered, “after she was freed, they had to pay her for her work. She was a free woman. Not a slave.”


Chairs began to scrape against the brick floor as one table after another cleared of their patrons, askin’ to be seated elsewhere. As far away from us as possible.


“Andrew Jackson may have been good to his slaves, Bonnie,’ I tried to whisper, “but nobody wants to be owned by another person. Can we talk about something else?”



What Bonnie shared with me at lunch in 1996 is the heart of the Lost Cause Narrative that fit so well into Mr. Scofield’s dispensationalism. In the 1860s, right after the war ended, the South chose to reconstruct history rather than allow for the Reconstruction of the South. Here’s how they did it.


Along with The Great Truth, stories like the one my sister told about the Jackson’s slave Aunt Hannah, praise “generous” slave owners who cared for happy an’ satisfied slaves. Myths of the Southern white man’s entitlement an’ his oppression after the Civil War, created a shelter for racial violence an’ terrorism. They reversed reconstruction an’ imposed white supremacy through Jim Crow laws.


This is the worst kind of sickness: denial. We rationalize an’ excuse vile behaviors to hide truths that cannot be faced. This way of thinkin’ an’ explainin’ this life, an’ the life hereafter, pervades the Fundamental Independent Baptist Church of my youth. White men were given dominion over the earth by God to do what they will. Jesus is comin’ soon anyway. So, what difference does it make?


The superiority of the white race was a given. In my church, white supremacy was disguised by male superiority an’ the enslaved were now the females among us. We’re told that we must accept that God wants things this way, that he designed ‘em this way. The implication bein’ that there is somethin’ wrong with those of us who are not happy ‘bout it.


Knowin’ where the South came from, is it any wonder this system of suppression is still so prevalent? Is the rise of Donald J. Trump an’ the execution of the January 6 insurrection any real surprise?


Like the South, my Mama was desperate to reconstruct her own history when she an’ Daddy moved our family a thousand miles away from every heartache an’ unhappiness they’d ever known. She got real good at denyin’ the truth an’ creatin’ her own mythology. Safely tucked away in our family’s old-growth heart wood, that truth would eventually refuse to be ignored.


The South felt so familiar, almost like she’d lived there before. It helped her re-write her narrative, an’ ours, in a way that could be tolerated.


One lie built upon another until the only way to get to the heart of the matter, an’ the treasure it held, meant total destruction. It would decimate the landscape, tearin’ ever’thing apart. Mama couldn’t let that happen. Her secrets were virgin forest territory, never touched by human hands. She would protect ‘em no matter what kinda lie she had to construct to do so.


The heart of the matter is the undeniable reality that gives ever’body—man, woman, child, red an’ yellow, black an’ white—a clear path to freedom. But that would mean tellin’ the truth. Well, the South I lived in couldn’t do that when I’s a kid. An’ the loudest voices currently speakin’ for the South today? So far as I can tell, they can’t do it either.


Just like my Mama.


Audio narration coming soon to YouTube

Comments


bottom of page